Sources
AOC Livestream: https://www.instagram.com/reel/Dfhp2DpiKh6/?utm_source=ig_web_copy_link&avpt=MzRlODBiNWFlZA==
Mascaro, Lisa. Hakeem Jeffries could become the first Black House speaker after Democratic nomination. AP. November 18, 2026. https://apnews.com/article/hakeem-jeffries-house-leadership-speaker-democrats-260433358f776473f29151992569f81d
Zhang, Sharon. Jeffries, Who’s Pledged to End Trump’s War on Iran, Says “No” on Defunding It. Truthout. November 18, 2026. https://truthout.org/articles/jeffries-whos-pledged-to-end-trumps-war-on-iran-says-no-on-defunding-it/
Bhakta, Mira. These 7 newly elected Democrats voted against Jeffries for House Speaker. The Hill. November 18, 2026. https://thehill.com/the-120/6228189-house-progressives-oppose-jeffries-leadership/
Parkinson, John. In historic move, House Democrats nominate Hakeem Jeffries for speaker of the House. ABC News. November 18, 2026. https://abcnews.com/Politics/hakeem-jeffries-poised-become-black-speaker-house/story?id=138119938
Transcript
In a closed door, back alley, dirty dog deal, the Democrats have officially nominated Hakeem Jeffries, the man literally none of us wanted, to be the uncontested speaker of the House of Representatives. The man who recycled a racist George Wallace quote promoting segregation in order to promote the apartheid state of Israel. Who called Jerusalem the 6th borough of New York and bragged about the number of times he’d traveled to Israel to “catch up with his constituents.” The man who spent the last two years sitting on his hands, completely incapable of meeting the moment and using any leverage available to him to try to stand up as fascism took over America. The man who this week said he has no intention of using the leverage he has in the upcoming budget negotiations next month to block funding for the Iran war, an incredibly expensive and unpopular war that most Americans don’t support. That’s the man that 251 Democratic representatives voted to nominate as speaker of the house on Wednesday, despite many of them, I would venture to guess most of them, receiving hundreds if not thousands of calls from their constituents, who they’re supposed to represent, telling them they want new leadership. Despite hundreds of thousands of Americans begging them to put forth someone to challenge Jeffries who isn’t completely bought out by special interests. Out of 260 or so Democratic representatives, not a single one threw their name into the ring to challenge Jeffries, despite his deplorably low approval rating with the voting public, despite his clear inadequacy for the job, despite a mandate from the people in this election that we want change.
You’re allowed to be disappointed. You’re allowed to be pissed. You’re allowed to stew in that anger because it is incredibly, deeply disappointing, and you’re not wrong for feeling like it was a slap in the face after a historic win that maybe had you feeling hope for the first time in a decade. I’m not gonna fucking patronize you by telling you this is just how it is. I am also, however, not going buy into doomerism and say well this is how it always is so what’s the point. That is my biggest fear in this outcome is that people who are interested in politics, maybe for the first time, who maybe voted for the first time ever or for a Democrat for the first time, who will think ok clearly my voice does not matter, I’m sitting this out, I’m tuning out and I’m giving in to apathy. I’m begging you not to take that route either. You can be big mad. I am. And also we move forward. So, they chose Hakeem Jeffries. What happens now?
AD
Thank you to my partner on today’s video, PDS Debt! Credit card debt SUCKS–I’ve struggled with it, I know how stressful and overwhelming it can feel to watch those debts pile up. And it’s so hard to live your life under the constant strain of worrying about credit card debt, on top of, you know, literally EVERYTHING ELSE going on right now. And of course it is the credit companies that win when you have to keep paying them huge amounts of interest every month. It can feel SO good to finally take back control of your life by tackling those big scary debts, especially if you can get a little help along the way. If you’re struggling with credit cards, personal loans, collections, or medical bills, you need to check out PDS Debt. PDS debt provides a service to match you with debt solutions tailored to your financial situation and they have a team of people ready to help you with your debt journey. They understand your specific scenario and will help provide alternative solutions to becoming debt free PDS debt is offering a free debt analysis. It only takes thirty seconds. Head over to PDSdebt.com/miller to get your free debt assessment today. You’ll receive a full breakdown on how to save on interest each month and the quickest way to take care of your debt. There is no minimum credit score required. Whether your credit is bad or fair, they’re here to help you save more, pay off your debt faster, and start putting money back where it belongs—in your savings account. PDS Debt is A+ rated by the Better Business Bureau, boasts hundreds of 5-star reviews on Google, and holds a 5-star rating on Trustpilot. And getting started is easy! Go to P D S Debt dot com slash miller to complete your free debt assessment in just 30 seconds to see what options are available to you. Get your free assessment and find the best option for you right now at P D S Debt dot com slash miller. Thanks PDS Debt!
First, let’s understand exactly what just happened. In order for business to begin, for the new House of Representatives to officially be in session come January, they have to vote on and elect a Speaker, which happens when the session begins in January. Ahead of that vote, the majority party gets together behind closed doors and holds a secret ballot to select their nominee for the speaker. That’s the part that just happened: they chose a nominee, they haven’t OFFICIALLY elected Hakeem Jeffries yet. When that vote was held on Wednesday, 251 Democrats voted for Hakeem Jeffries, only 11 representatives voted against Jeffries, which is an abysmal and disappointing showing given how loud the call was to replace him with someone else. Again these are secret ballots so Representatives can choose whether or not to make their votes public. The members who voted against Jeffries and made their vote public were Don Leonard of Ohio, Angela Gonzales-Torres of California, Darializa Avila Chevalier from New York, Adam Hamawy from New Jersey, Frederick Haynes from Texas, Melat Kiros from Colorado, Donavan McKinney from Michigan, Chris Rabb from Pennsylvania, and Claire Valdez from New York. Those last seven, all DSA candidates, issued a joint statement saying quote “We have worked to secure commitments from Leader Jeffries in good-faith conversations. While we have seen meaningful progress, there is still work to be done to ensure that the direction our party takes this coming Congress reflects what our constituents are demanding of leadership. Those conversations are ongoing. As such, our vote in caucus today was no.”
That statement tells me two things: one is that the opposition to Jeffries that came from us, the people, agitating, calling our representatives, making the mainstream media pay attention (even though they often played it down as only coming from the “far left” which is inaccurate given his extremely low approval ratings), all of it, gave them leverage and forced Jeffries to sit down and have individual conversations with the new Representatives, and I can’t imagine he would have taken them very seriously if there wasn’t so much public push against him. I do think it made him sweat under the collar a little bit even if he would never admit it. It forced him to pay attention to the left flank of his caucus and not write them off as a fluke or as extreme. The other thing that joint statement tells me is that even as he sat down with these newly elected representatives, they couldn’t get him to concede his pro Israel, pro corporate, centrist positions. That the conversations were perhaps productive but ultimately unpersuasive to Jeffries. On the one hand I don’t think it’s fair to have put all of that pressure on this brand new incoming class of freshman lawmakers, I think the progressive wing of the party who has been there longer who understand the ropes, Ilhan Omar, AOC, Ayanna Pressley, I think they should have showed more support to back these new lawmakers and push Jeffries harder on his positions. They may have done that behind the scenes more than we know but that’s the thing: we don’t know. And I think that’s the larger question that a lot of people are asking: why is this how it works?
Why is everything secretive, why are secret ballots even a thing, why can we not see the behind the scenes inner workings of the people representing us, of the government we pay for? Why do we have to guess at the negotiations and conversations that happened behind closed doors in our name? I think the MAGA movement has done a good job in that regard—not the transparency part, but the questioning why things are the way they are part. They have come in and questioned the system itself and reformed it or did away with things they thought weren’t working. It was to all of our detriment, to be clear, and it was for evil and nefarious purposes, but they haven’t been afraid to boldly ask how can we manipulate this system to serve our needs? In a way that the left never seems willing to do. Now of course our legislators are supposed to go to Congress to do the investigation and legislation that is Congress’ job, it can’t all be upending procedural rules and things that are done just because it’s “how they’ve always been done” they do need to write and pass laws as well, but por que no los dos, ya know? Can we not walk and chew gum at the same time? The Constitution doesn’t declare how the house should pick a speaker, it just tells them to do it. The way it’s done is only set in stone because it’s how it’s always been done. I think it’s absolutely a worthwhile conversation to be having around the procedure and the process because every process should be audited occasionally to see if it’s really the best way to be doing something. Just doing something the same way because it’s how it’s always been done is not a good enough reason, when how it’s always been done isn’t serving the will of the people from whom the legitimacy of the entire government is supposed to be derived. So even though Jeffries was ultimately selected I still think this has been a very worthwhile exercise in civic engagement to be looking at and questioning and agitating around these usually pretty banal things that few people pay attention to.
Okay, so why did they pick him. Why did only 11 representatives side with us, the people? I do think we have to include race in this discussion, I know you hate to hear a white woman say that, please bear with me. Hakeem Jeffries if elected to the speakership will be the first black person ever elected to serve as the speaker of the house. That is a really big deal and for some members of the Black Caucus that is a bigger deal than the actual policies or platforms Jeffries represents. It’s a complicated choice I can’t personally speak to but I think race did play an important role in some peoples’ votes. Do I think there are better black Representatives they could have chosen from? Absolutely. But we can’t discount that as a factor here.
Secondly, we need to talk about AOC. Alexandria Ocasio Cortez of New York. She voted to support Jeffries and her, along with Ayanna Pressley and pretty much any other Representative coming out announcing their support of Jeffries and even those like Ilhan Omar who didn’t announce she voted for him but clearly is not among the people who opposed him, all of them are getting a flood of negative comments on their social media and I imagine via phone calls as well. Like I said, the people are rightfully mad. And when we are told “well there’s no one to run against him so like our hands are tied” that is an additional slap in the face and insult to our intelligence. Yes thank you we see that, we’re asking you to find someone to do it. Also despite there being no one running against him, 11 people managed to figure out how to indicate they don’t support him on the vote so their defense for how they voted falls apart under even an ounce of scrutiny.
All that being said, I think AOC did a really informative and important livestream on her Instagram about a week ago that I wanted to highlight because I do think it is worth discussing. A lot of people dismissed this livestream as her just using a white board to try to explain the process to us instead of doing anything about it, but I do want to give her some credit because I actually watched the livestream instead of just rage posting about it and it is incredibly rare to get this level of insight into the inner workings of congress and this level of candor from a politician, and I think part of the reason why more politicians don’t do these more informal styles of communication with the public is because people jump down their fucking throats and expect perfection from them. I mean this is a perennial problem within the left—where’s the line between agitating and holding electeds accountable versus holding electeds to an unrealistic ideological purity that ends up just biting you in the ass. Because at the end of the day there is ideology and then there is the act of politicking and while you’d hope the two overlap, it is not realistic to expect ideological purity from politicians navigating the act of politicking. The act of politicking requires working within a coalition of people with many different viewpoints and being able to form the right relationships and make the right strategic moves to serve your ultimate end goal. Which means necessarily that sometimes you have to make moves or decisions that don’t perfectly align with ideological purity because you have to compromise with the people in the room with you in order to get shit done. But at the same time it is also our job to hold our electeds accountable, to push for the change we want to see, and to impress our ideological preferences on our electeds. Politicians do not lead, they follow. They do not lead, they follow our lead. They need us to push them before they will get anything done. So it’s a both and—we push, we agitate, and we also recognize the reality of the system that these elected officials are operating within. And AOC does a commendable job of trying to elucidate some of the inner workings of the POLITICS of this process in the livestream I’m mentioning, in a way that no other politician is really doing right now.
I’ve linked the full livestream in the sources, but I think the most insightful takeaway I got from the livestream is about what happens next now that Jeffries has been chosen as the party’s nominee. So, like I said, before any business can be held on the floor of the House, they have to vote in a Speaker. So that vote will happen in January. Just because someone is voted as the nominee doesn’t mean everyone has to vote for him. So there is still the opportunity for opposition against Jeffries to hold up the vote for speaker so he doesn’t have the votes, to force them to look for someone else. That is still on the table. However, this is where the procedure for how this all happens gets rather fucked up. Basically, the house vote for speaker happens first. Everyone in the chamber stands up and says who they vote for for speaker, or they can abstain so that the speaker doesn’t have the majority needed to move forward. Pretty much right after that public vote happens, in which we’re asking our representatives to look Jeffries in the face and tell him no, if he manages to get the votes anyway, which I mean based on the abysmal showing of opposition to him even at the nomination stage is looking pretty likely, so if he does win and you just got done telling him you don’t support him, what happens next? The speaker is in charge of doling out committee assignments. And if a very petty person was just chosen to be speaker of the house, and let’s be real they’re all politicians so they’re all going to be petty you have no other option, then you just told a very petty person that you don’t support them and now they get to decide where you’re spending all your time for the next two years. And there are some committees that spearhead very public investigations which can be careermaking—how many of the most visible members of Congress have you seen in viral clips engaging in a fiery back and forth with someone they’ve called before them to question—that can raise a person’s public profile and is really good for winning future elections. Other committees are in charge of passing a shit ton of legislation, some see WAY more legislation that others, and some committees are obscure, behind the scenes work that doesn’t get much attention. You could be put in a back broom closet against your will. And there are specific topics and issues that lawmakers go to Congress wanting to champion, like affordable healthcare or abolishing ICE, and there are certain committees that have jurisdiction over those issues where you could do a lot of great work if you get the assignment you want. Do you think you’ll get the assignment you want if you just told the person doing the assigning that you don’t support them? Your relationship with the speaker of the house has a major impact on your success as a representative not just your public image or fame but also your ability to do the work you promised your constituents you would do.
Additionally, because our elections are bought and sold by monied interests and lobbyists, the person who controls the purse strings for fundraising in the house has a lot of sway over who gets money to run their future campaigns for election and re-election. In the house, the committee in charge of fundraising for Democrats is called the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee, or DCCC. They recruit and organize races and candidates, and they fundraise and then dole out those funds to Democrats running for a seat in the house. The chair of the DCCC is chosen by party leadership, the head of which is of course the speaker of the house. So the speaker plays a role in fundraising and in election campaigns for all Democrats that want to hold on to their seat in the future. That is also weighing on peoples’ minds as they contemplate whether they’re ready to stand up and tell Jeffries they don’t support him in January.
And so part of the equation that these members are using for their calculations includes this reality—that their committee membership dictates their career in congress, their ability to serve their constituents in the way they said they would, and that in turn is dictated by the Speaker, who also dictates whether they have money to run their next election. And so unless there is a good chance that there is enough opposition to mount a true challenge to the leadership position, which is not looking good, then they’re likely not going to be willing to put their neck on the line and risk either their political ambitions or their ability to serve their constituents. To clarify, all members of the house, of both parties, vote on the speaker of the house, who needs a simple majority to win. Republicans will vote no of course but the speaker needs 212 votes to win, and out of 260 Democrats in the House come January only 11 opposed him at the nominating stage. That math isn’t going to math for representatives considering opposing Jeffries. When the party with the majority has a slimmer margin, that’s when the people who oppose the speaker nomination get a bit more leverage, which is why there was so much upheaval when Republicans were trying to pick a speaker a few years ago and the house freedom caucus, the far right members of the party, was able to fuck shit up despite having relatively small numbers. Their majority was very slim. That is unfortunately not the case when it comes to the progressive caucus in the house, which is greatly outnumbered by establishment democrats.
A few things about this. Having this information is so important because it arms you with better arguments. First of all, this makes me even more pissed that more progressives didn’t stand up to Jeffries at the nominating stage. It could have given them the opportunity to mount a true opposition to Jeffries, to push him further on the issues, to hold his feet to the fire, to present someone else as an alternative option for the Democrats to vote on. And then if, despite their very best efforts, he still won the nomination, THEN stand up on the first day of session in January and say you support Jeffries. And then you sell that to your constituents—you say I did my best to advocate for you when it mattered, when we were having internal party discussions and debate on the issue, when as a party we were figuring out who to put forward publicly on the floor of the house, and I was outvoted. We had a contested election and I was outvoted by a democratic majority, and now that it’s going to the house floor, we must move forward with what we have and form a united opposition in the face of the fascist party that has been running things and ruining everything for you over the past two years. So number one, I’m pissed. Progressives dropped the fucking ball when it mattered most. I understand there was no one running against him, SOMEONE SHOULD HAVE. The fact that no one was willing to shows a lack of courage that is fucking shameful.
Number two, knowing this information helps us to identify the parts of the system that clearly aren’t working for the people, and I’m pissed that no one in Congress who, again, makes their own rules for how they run things, why no one is agitating for some of these things to change. First of all, we could change the way committee assignments work. It could be changed so that some independent or separate group doles out committee assignments and not the speaker of the house, so that there isn’t this giant threat being wielded over the heads of everyone in the party to vote for the right person or else face immediate consequences. We could remove the ability for the speaker to be petty, thus allowing Representatives to vote for what their constituents want without fear of retaliation.
Second of all if money didn’t play such a huge role in our politics, the fact that the Speaker controls the purse strings for future fundraising wouldn’t hold so much sway. Representatives wouldn’t be in a perpetual state of fundraising because they have to win an election every two years and the only way to do it is to make rich people happy. Which I will give AOC credit for again, she has managed to win many elections despite this reality without taking corporate PAC money or AIPAC money, which in the livestream I mentioned before she said means she has a lot more freedom and agency over her work in Congress, not because someone with money is holding a knife to the backs of all the other members but because when you need corporate money to win elections, those people become the only people you talk to, and so your ability to actually serve your constituents becomes blurred because you never talk to your constituents you’re constantly talking to major donors and licking their boots. These are incredibly fixable issues and at least for the first point about committee assignments I’m not seeing anyone in the House push for that to be changed, instead it’s simply being presented to us as just “how things are done” even though again Congress makes its own damn rules.
Okay so what do we do. I am LOATHE to admit defeat before it’s all said and done and Jeffries ain’t speaker YET, so I still think it’s worth it to call your representatives and tell them you’re disappointed and tell them you don’t want that man as speaker. And I think this is important because what we ARE being told from some electeds, I’m thinking specifically of that official statement from the DSA reps as well as a video that Ayanna Pressley posted that really was a non-excuse for her support of Jeffries but in both instances they were saying that our opposition to Jeffries, our voices, our agitation, our work, is giving them leverages in conversations within the Democratic party, and that does matter. Because when they can point to hundreds of calls from constituents, hundreds of thousands of petition signatures, real agitation from their base with a cohesive message, that gives them leverage for pushing progressive causes through Congress. That helps pull the overton window back to the left, it helps push for change. Again, politicians do not lead, they follow us. They will not do anything unless we grab them by the nose and force them to. And our job is to continue electing people that will use that leverage for progressive causes, which I think especially these DSA candidates will. Now that brings me to another thing I’ve been thinking about and grappling with.
One way to get through to your representatives is to threaten them with primaries, to threaten their ability to hold down their position of power. Politicians hate that shit. So I think it’s worthwhile to consider whether your representative is someone who should be primaried if they made the wrong call on this and if they don’t redeem themselves or explain themselves or in any other way win your support back. And like with ideological purity tests I don’t think we can be black and white about this. It is not good strategy to say let’s primary all of them. For example, my representative is Ilhan Omar and she voted for Jeffries. And see now Ilhan’s gone and put me in a bind. Because on the one hand I understand calls for primarying Democrats who don’t listen to their constituents. On the other hand again this isn’t an ideological purity test, this is politics, and politics require strategy. This isn’t a fucking game, this is peoples’ lives and health and livelihood and wellbeing, but you have to have nuance when you are working within the system and working with a large coalition of varying interests. You have to have nuance, I am begging you to have nuance. And for me, with Ilhan Omar, the nuance is that she is an incredibly popular candidate, she won 76% of the vote in November in her district and she won her primary with over 80% of the vote. And despite her support for Jeffries, which as far as I can tell she hasn’t issued any explanation for as of this moment, she is one of the most progressive members of Congress. Being a purist and saying we’re going to primary everyone who makes the wrong decision isn’t realistic not only because in the case of Ilhan Omar she is SO popular in her district and she IS, on the whole, doing good progressive work. My initial knee jerk reaction was let’s primary all of them, because I was mad, but the reality is so much more nuanced and strategic. I don’t think primarying some of our most progressive voices in Congress is the correct move, and we would be better served if we focus on primarying Democrats who are centrist and conservative with more progressive candidates so that we move the needle to the left within the party. And that’s part of the long game.
So in the short run, call your representatives and also CALL YOUR SENATORS. The vote for Senate Majority Leader doesn’t happen for a couple weeks and Van Hollen has a real shot at winning. He is the man for this moment, I made a whole video laying out why, and even if Jeffries does get the speakership, having to partner with someone to his left like Van Hollen will force him to take more progressive initiatives and voices into account. Tell your Senators you’re watching, tell them you support Van Hollen and you expect them to as well. Van Hollen is on the progressive side of things like Medicare for all, ending aid to Israel, ending the war in Iran, ending Citizens United, the things that the vast majority of Americans want and that would benefit the vast majority of Americans, Chris Van Hollen gets it, Chuck Schumer does not, and there is real opposition to Chuck Schumer in the Senate and our senators can’t hide behind the excuse that there’s no one running against him, like our representatives did. We have a shot at replacing Schumer with a really good alternative and can really move the needle.
So don’t admit defeat yet. Because the thing about progress is that it is never as satisfying as you want it to be. When you are a progressive, when you are someone who doesn’t fall in the corporatist center, which I think most of my audience does not, then you want BETTER, you want the powerful to spread their power around, to spread the wealth around, to protect the vulnerable, to use resources to benefit everyone, you want progress towards a more just, egalitarian society. But for every bit of progress, there is often a backlash to that progress, and every win has to be hard fought. I wish it weren’t that way, but that’s the reality of it. You will never be satisfied. That’s part of the bag when it comes to being a progressive. There will always be people pulling backwards while you try to pull forwards, and sometimes they’ll win. And the amount you pull forwards is never going to be enough, you’re never going to arrive at a place where you say ah yes perfect the United States is a bastion of progressivism the way I’ve always envisioned it could be. That’s never going to happen. And I don’t say that to you in a pessimistic way, I say it to you as a pep talk. Because the sooner you get used to this feeling, that you celebrate every win and you keep pushing because it’s never enough, because that’s the work of being a progressive, the better activist, citizen, agitator you will be. It helps with your resolve if you just accept that fact and keep pushing forward anyway. We get used to disappointment and yet we do not accept defeat. As I always say, voting is literally the least you can do. And I think for a lot of people this midterm season has us tuned into electoral politics in a way we haven’t been before. I can’t remember a time when there’s been this much agitation over the back room selection of party leadership, this often goes by unnoticed and uncontested. The one silver lining of the awful past two years is that the people are fucking awake. And now it’s time to lock the fuck in and do the work to hold our politicians accountable and do whatever we can to push for an agenda that could make America truly great not again but for the first time. Make America Great For The First Time, doesn’t really fit on a hat but there’s gotta be a slogan in there somewhere.
Anyway, this is my pep talk to you. You’re allowed to be mad and disappointed about Jeffries, but Schumer is still on the chopping block and we can’t give up that easy. That’s what they want you to do. I’m ready to prove them wrong out of the sheer power of the combination of spite and hope. And they can’t take that away from us.
To get these videos ad free you can join my Patreon where I also share special extra content that doesn’t make the main edit. Thank you to my multi-platinum patrons Sarah Shelby, Art, David, L’etranger (Lukus), Thomas Johnson, and Tay. Your generosity makes this channel what it is, so thank you!
If you liked this video, you’ll like my video from Wednesday about why everything is breaking.